| □ | 1951 | Marriott, John | Norwood |
| □ | 1952 | Fitzgerald, Len | Sturt |
| □ | 1955 | Head, Lindsay | West Torrens |
| □ | 1956 | Boyd, Dave | Port Adel Magpies |
| □ | 1957 | Johns, Rex | Port Adel Magpies |
| □ | 1957 | Benton, Ron | West Adelaide |
| □ | 1958 | Williams, Fos | Port Adel Magpies |
| □ | 1959 | Fitzgerald, Len | Sturt |